Have you ever reached into your pantry, grabbed a potato, and noticed small green shoots growing out of it? It’s a common kitchen dilemma: should you toss it in the trash or simply cut off the sprouts and cook it as usual? The answer isn’t as straightforward as many people think. Food safety experts say that while sprouted potatoes aren’t automatically dangerous, there are important things you need to know before putting them on your plate.
Table of Contents
Why Do Potatoes Sprout?
Potatoes are living plants, even after they’re harvested. When stored in warm, humid, or bright conditions, they naturally begin to sprout as part of their growth cycle. Those little “eyes” start developing shoots in an attempt to grow into a new potato plant.
Sprouting is more common when potatoes are stored:
- At room temperature for long periods
- In direct sunlight
- In humid environments
- Near onions (which release gases that speed up sprouting)
While sprouting itself doesn’t mean the potato is spoiled, it can signal chemical changes happening inside.
The Real Concern: Solanine
According to food safety specialists, the biggest issue with sprouted potatoes is a natural toxin called solanine. Potatoes produce solanine and related compounds (glycoalkaloids) as a defense mechanism against pests and disease.
When a potato sprouts or turns green, solanine levels can increase — especially in:
- The sprouts
- The green skin
- Areas just under the peel
Consuming high levels of solanine can cause symptoms such as:
- Nausea
- Vomiting
- Diarrhea
- Stomach cramps
- Headaches
In severe cases, though rare, it can lead to more serious health effects.
Can You Simply Cut Off the Sprouts?
Many experts say that if a potato is still firm and only has small sprouts, you can usually make it safe by:
- Cutting off the sprouts completely
- Removing any green areas
- Peeling the skin thoroughly
If the potato underneath is firm, white (not green), and doesn’t smell bad, it may still be safe to eat.
However, if the potato is:
- Very shriveled
- Soft or wrinkled
- Deeply green
- Bitter-tasting
It’s best to throw it away.
What About Green Potatoes?
The green color on potatoes is caused by chlorophyll, which itself isn’t harmful. But the green appearance often indicates higher solanine levels.
Experts recommend avoiding potatoes that are heavily green. If only a small area is slightly green, cutting away that portion generously may reduce risk. If most of the potato has turned green, it’s safer not to eat it.
Does Cooking Destroy the Toxin?
One common myth is that cooking eliminates the toxin. Unfortunately, solanine is heat-stable, meaning normal cooking temperatures — boiling, baking, frying — do not significantly reduce it.
That’s why proper trimming and inspection are so important. You can’t rely on heat alone to make a heavily sprouted or green potato safe.
Who Should Be Extra Careful?
While most healthy adults are unlikely to experience severe effects from small amounts of solanine, certain groups should be more cautious:
- Young children
- Pregnant women
- People with digestive sensitivities
- Individuals with compromised immune systems
For these groups, it’s better to avoid questionable potatoes altogether.
How to Store Potatoes Properly
Prevention is always better than waste. To keep potatoes fresh longer and prevent sprouting:
- Store them in a cool, dark place (ideally 45–50°F / 7–10°C)
- Avoid refrigeration, which can alter taste and texture
- Keep them in a breathable container (paper bag or basket)
- Store away from onions
Proper storage can significantly slow down sprouting and reduce toxin buildup.
Are Sprouted Potatoes Ever Completely Unsafe?
In extreme cases — especially if potatoes taste bitter — they should not be eaten. Bitterness is often a warning sign of high glycoalkaloid content.
Food scientists emphasize that your senses are helpful indicators:
- If it smells normal and feels firm, it may be salvageable.
- If it looks shriveled, green, or tastes bitter, discard it.
When in doubt, throwing it out is the safest option.
The Bottom Line
So, can you eat sprouted potatoes? Experts say yes — but with caution.
If the potato is still firm and only lightly sprouted, removing the sprouts and peeling away any green areas may make it safe to cook and eat. However, heavily sprouted, green, shriveled, or bitter potatoes should be discarded to avoid potential solanine exposure.
At the end of the day, your health is worth more than a single potato. A quick inspection before cooking can help you avoid unnecessary risks while reducing food waste at the same time.
